📚 Millikan’s Oil Drop Experiment and the Determination of Elementary Charge | 密立根油滴实验与基本电荷测定
The Millikan oil drop experiment is one of the most celebrated experiments in the history of physics. Performed by Robert A. Millikan and Harvey Fletcher in 1909, it provided the first direct and convincing measurement of the elementary electric charge, e. By observing tiny charged oil droplets suspended in an electric field, Millikan demonstrated that electric charge is quantised and exists in integer multiples of a fundamental unit. This article explores the experimental setup, underlying theory, key calculations, and the profound implications of this landmark investigation.
密立根油滴实验是物理学史上最著名的实验之一。1909年由罗伯特·密立根和哈维·弗莱彻完成，首次直接且令人信服地测量了基本电荷e。通过观察带电油滴在电场中的悬浮状态，密立根证明了电荷是量子化的，并以基本单位的整数倍存在。本文探讨该实验的装置、基本原理、关键计算以及这一里程碑式研究的深远意义。
1. Introduction | 引言
The concept that electric charge comes in discrete packets is fundamental to our understanding of matter. Before Millikan’s work, the electron had been identified by J.J. Thomson, but its charge was only known approximately. Millikan’s oil drop experiment provided a precision measurement of the charge on the electron, confirming that all charges are integral multiples of a smallest unit, e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C. The experiment beautifully combines classical mechanics, electrostatics, and fluid dynamics to reveal a quantum property of nature.
电荷以离散包形式存在的概念是我们理解物质的基础。在密立根的工作之前，J.J.汤姆逊已经发现了电子，但其电荷仅是近似已知。密立根油滴实验精确测量了电子电荷，证实所有电荷都是最小单位e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C的整数倍。这个实验巧妙地结合了经典力学、静电学和流体动力学，揭示了自然的量子属性。
2. Historical Background | 历史背景
In 1897, J.J. Thomson measured the charge-to-mass ratio (e/m) of cathode rays, proving they were particles — electrons. However, neither e nor m was individually known with high accuracy. Around the same time, scientists observed that water droplets in cloud chambers tended to acquire electric charges. Millikan and Fletcher refined this idea, using oil instead of water because oil evaporates much more slowly, allowing a single drop to be observed for hours. Their result, published in 1913, earned Millikan the 1923 Nobel Prize in Physics. The experiment was so precise that the accepted value of e remained essentially unchanged for decades.
1897年，J.J.汤姆逊测量了阴极射线的荷质比（e/m），证明它们是粒子——电子。然而，e和m的单个精确值还不清楚。大约同时期，科学家观察到云室中的水滴倾向于获得电荷。密立根和弗莱彻改进了这一思路，用油代替水，因为油蒸发慢得多，可以观察单个油滴数小时。他们在1913年发表的结果使密立根获得了1923年诺贝尔物理学奖。该实验如此精确，以至于公认的e值几十年来基本保持不变。
3. Experimental Setup | 实验装置
The apparatus consisted of two horizontal metal plates forming a parallel-plate capacitor, separated by a few millimetres. A fine spray of oil droplets was introduced between the plates through a small hole in the top plate. A light source illuminated the droplets from the side, and a microscope allowed observation of individual droplets as they fell under gravity or were influenced by an electric field. The plates were connected to a high-voltage DC supply that could be varied and reversed. A timer was used to measure the terminal velocity of a droplet moving under specific conditions.
实验装置由两块水平的金属板组成一个间距几毫米的平行板电容器。通过上板的小孔引入细小的油滴喷雾。光源从侧面照亮油滴，显微镜用于观察单个油滴在重力或电场影响下降落的过程。两板连接到一个可调并可反向的高压直流电源。使用计时器测量油滴在特定条件下的终极速度。
4. Theory: Forces on an Oil Drop | 原理：油滴上的力
An oil drop of mass m and radius r falling through air experiences three main forces: its weight (mg downward), the buoyant force due to displaced air (upward), and a viscous drag force given by Stokes’ law, Fd = 6πηrv, where η is the viscosity of air and v is the downward velocity. When the drop reaches terminal velocity v₁, the net force is zero. If the droplet carries a charge q and a uniform electric field E = V/d is applied (with V the voltage and d the plate separation), an electric force qE acts on it. By adjusting V, the drop can be held stationary (v = 0). Balancing forces gives qE = (m – mair)g, where mair is the mass of displaced air.
质量为m、半径为r的油滴在空气中下落时受到三个主要力的作用：重力（向下）、排开空气的浮力（向上）和根据斯托克斯定律的粘滞阻力Fd = 6πηrv，其中η是空气粘滞系数，v是下落速度。当油滴达到终极速度v₁时，合力为零。如果油滴带有电荷q，并施加匀强电场E = V/d（V为电压，d为板间距），则会受到电场力qE。通过调节V，可以使油滴静止（v = 0）。平衡力给出qE = (m – mair)g，其中mair是排开空气的质量。
5. The Balanced Field Method | 平衡场法
In the simplest approach, the electric field is adjusted so that the droplet is held motionless. Then, qE = (4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g, where ρoil and ρair are the densities of oil and air. However, r is not directly known. To find r, the field is switched off and the droplet is allowed to fall under gravity. Its terminal velocity v₁ is measured. At terminal velocity, (4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g = 6πηrv₁. Solving for r gives r = √[9ηv₁ / 2(ρoil – ρair)g]. Substituting this r back into the balance equation yields the charge q. Millikan found that the values of q were always small integer multiples of approximately 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ C.
在最简单的方法中，调节电场使油滴保持静止。那么qE = (4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g，其中ρoil和ρair分别是油和空气的密度。然而，半径r无法直接得知。为求得r，撤去电场让油滴在重力下落。测量其终极速度v₁。在终极速度时，(4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g = 6πηrv₁。解得r = √[9ηv₁ / 2(ρoil – ρair)g]。将r代回平衡方程可得到电荷q。密立根发现q的值总是大约1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ C的小整数倍。
6. The Dynamic (Falling) Method | 动态（降落）法
A more accurate method involves measuring the terminal velocities with and without the electric field. The droplet is first allowed to fall freely; terminal velocity v₁ is recorded. Then an upward electric field is applied, causing the droplet to move upward with terminal velocity v₂. The equations of motion become: without field, (4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g = 6πηrv₁. With field, qE – (4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g = 6πηrv₂. Adding these equations eliminates the effective weight and allows direct calculation of q from measured velocities and known constants. This method reduces uncertainty because the same droplet is used, and the radius cancels out.
一种更精确的方法是在有电场和无电场时测量终极速度。首先让油滴自由下落，记录终极速度v₁。然后施加向上的电场，使油滴以终极速度v₂向上运动。运动方程为：无场时，(4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g = 6πηrv₁。有场时，qE – (4/3)πr³(ρoil – ρair)g = 6πηrv₂。将两方程相加消去有效重量，从测得的速度和已知常数直接计算q。该方法降低了不确定性，因为使用同一油滴且半径被消去。
7. Stokes’ Law Correction | 斯托克斯定律修正
Stokes’ law F = 6πηrv assumes a continuous fluid. However, when the droplet radius r becomes comparable to the mean free path λ of air molecules, the drag force is reduced because the drop slips between molecules. Millikan introduced a correction factor: ηeff = η / (1 + b/pr), where b is an empirical constant and p is the atmospheric pressure. The corrected terminal velocity equation becomes more complex, but it yields a much more accurate value for r and thus for q. Typically, for oil drops of radius ~10⁻⁶ m, the correction is a few percent.
斯托克斯定律F = 6πηrv假设流体是连续的。但当油滴半径r与空气分子平均自由程λ可比时，阻力会减小，因为油滴在分子间滑过。密立根引入修正因子：ηeff = η / (1 + b/pr)，其中b是经验常数，p是大气压。修正后的终极速度方程变得复杂，但能给出更准确的r和q。对于半径约10⁻⁶ m的油滴，修正量约为百分之几。
8. Determining the Charge Quantization | 确定电荷量子化
Millikan repeated the experiment on hundreds of individual droplets, measuring q each time. He observed that all q values were multiples of a smallest common factor. He plotted the charges and noticed they clustered around integer multiples of a basic unit. By taking the greatest common divisor of the charge differences, he deduced the elementary charge e = 1.592 × 10⁻¹⁹ C (his original value, later refined). This directly demonstrated that electric charge is quantised and that the electron carries exactly one negative unit of this fundamental charge.
密立根对数百个单个油滴重复实验，每次测量q。他观察到所有q值都是一个最小公因数的倍数。他画出电荷图，发现它们聚集在某个基本单位的整数倍附近。通过取电荷差的最大公约数，他推导出基本电荷e = 1.592 × 10⁻¹⁹ C（原始值，后经修正）。这直接证明了电荷是量子化的，电子恰好携带一个单位的这种基本负电荷。
9. Worked Example | 示例计算
Consider an oil drop of density 920 kg m⁻³ in air (density 1.2 kg m⁻³). The plate separation is 5.0 mm, and the viscosity of air is 1.80 × 10⁻⁵ Pa s. Without the field, the drop falls at a terminal speed of 2.0 × 10⁻⁴ m s⁻¹. Find its radius and mass. With a voltage of 510 V, the drop is held stationary. Find the charge on the drop and express it as a multiple of e = 1.60 × 10⁻¹⁹ C.
考虑一个密度为920 kg m⁻³的油滴（空气密度1.2 kg m⁻³）。板间距5.0 mm，空气粘滞系数1.80 × 10⁻⁵ Pa s。无电场时，油滴以2.0 × 10⁻⁴ m s⁻¹的终极速度下落。求其半径和质量。施加510 V电压时油滴静止。求油滴电荷，并表示为e = 1.60 × 10⁻¹⁹ C的倍数。
First, radius from terminal velocity: r = √[9ηv₁ / 2(ρoil – ρair)g]
= √[9 × 1.80×10⁻⁵ × 2.0×10⁻⁴ / (2 × (920 – 1.2) × 9.81)]
= √[3.24×10⁻⁹ / 18028] ≈ √(1.797×10⁻¹³) = 4.24×10⁻⁷ m.
Mass = (4/3)πr³ρoil ≈ (4/3)π(4.24×10⁻⁷)³ × 920 ≈ 2.9×10⁻¹⁶ kg.
At balance, qE = mg (neglecting buoyancy for simplicity; buoyancy correction is small). E = V/d = 510 / 0.005 = 1.02×10⁵ V m⁻¹.
q = mg/E = (2.9×10⁻¹⁶ × 9.81) / 1.02×10⁵ ≈ 2.78×10⁻¹⁹ C.
Number of excess electrons = q/e ≈ 2.78×10⁻¹⁹ / 1.60×10⁻¹⁹ ≈ 1.74. Since charge must be integer multiple, the nearest integer is n = 2 (q = 3.20×10⁻¹⁹ C) or n = 1. The discrepancy arises from approximations; the actual drop likely carried 2e.
首先，由终极速度求半径：r = √[9ηv₁ / 2(ρoil – ρair)g] = √[9 × 1.80×10⁻⁵ × 2.0×10⁻⁴ / (2 × (920 – 1.2) × 9.81)] ≈ √(1.797×10⁻¹³) = 4.24×10⁻⁷ m。质量m = (4/3)πr³ρoil ≈ 2.9×10⁻¹⁶ kg。平衡时，qE = mg（忽略浮力，修正很小）。E = V/d = 510/0.005 = 1.02×10⁵ V m⁻¹。q = mg/E ≈ 2.78×10⁻¹⁹ C。元电荷数 = q/e ≈ 1.74。因电荷必为整数倍，最接近整数n=2（q=3.20×10⁻¹⁹ C）或n=1。差异来自近似；实际油滴可能携带2e。
10. Key Results and the Value of e | 关键结果与e值
Millikan’s 1913 paper reported e = 1.592 × 10⁻¹⁹ C with an uncertainty of about 0.2%. Later re-evaluation with corrected viscosity values gave e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C, which is accepted today. The experiment also allowed Millikan to assert that fractional charges do not exist under normal conditions — all charges are integer multiples of e. This result heralded the quantum age and confirmed the particulate nature of electricity.
密立根1913年的论文报告e = 1.592 × 10⁻¹⁹ C，不确定度约0.2%。后经粘滞系数修正重新评估，得到e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C，即今日公认值。该实验也使密立根断言在正常条件下不存在分数电荷——所有电荷都是e的整数倍。这一结果预示了量子时代的到来，并证实了电的粒子性。
11. Sources of Error and Limitations | 误差来源与局限性
Major error sources include: evaporation of oil droplets altering mass; convection currents in the chamber; inaccuracies in timing terminal velocities; the uncertainty in air viscosity; the correction for molecular slip (Stokes law breakdown); and difficulty in measuring small changes in voltage. Additionally, Millikan’s original data selection has been scrutinised; he reportedly excluded droplets that did not fit integer multiples, although modern analyses confirm the validity of his conclusions.
主要误差来源包括：油滴的蒸发改变质量；腔体内的对流；终极速度计时的不准确性；空气粘滞系数的不确定性；分子滑移修正（斯托克斯定律失效）；以及测量微小电压变化的困难。另外，密立根原始数据的筛选受到审视；据报道他排除了不符合整数倍的油滴，但现代分析证实了他结论的有效性。
12. Significance in Modern Physics | 在现代物理学中的意义
The oil drop experiment is a cornerstone of modern physics. It directly demonstrated charge quantization and determined the fundamental charge e, which underpins the standard model of particle physics. The value of e is used to define the ampere (via the Coulomb), and it plays a crucial role in atomic structure, quantum mechanics, and electronics. The experiment itself remains a classic in undergraduate physics laboratories, teaching precise measurement techniques, scientific deduction, and the interplay between theory and experiment.
油滴实验是现代物理学的基石。它直接证明了电荷的量子化，并确定了基本电荷e，这是粒子物理学标准模型的基础。e值用于定义安培（通过库仑），并在原子结构、量子力学和电子学中起着关键作用。该实验本身仍是本科物理实验室的经典，传授精密测量技术、科学推理以及理论与实验的相互作用。
Published by TutorHao | Physics Revision Series | aleveler.com
更多咨询请联系16621398022（同微信）
屏轩国际教育cambridge primary/secondary checkpoint, cat4, ukiset,ukcat,igcse,alevel,PAT,STEP,MAT, ibdp,ap,ssat,sat,sat2课程辅导，国外大学本科硕士研究生博士课程论文辅导