📚 Domestic Politics in Wilhelmine Germany | 威廉时期德国的国内政治
The Wilhelmine era (1888–1918) represents one of the most dynamic and contradictory periods in modern German history. Under Kaiser Wilhelm II, Germany experienced extraordinary industrial expansion and global ambition, yet its domestic political system remained deeply fractured along class, religious, and regional lines. This article examines the key structures, actors, and tensions that defined German domestic politics from Wilhelm II’s accession to the eve of the First World War.
威廉时代（1888–1918 年）是德国现代史上最具活力也最充满矛盾的时期之一。在威廉二世皇帝的统治下，德国经历了非凡的工业扩张和全球野心，但其国内政治体系却始终因阶级、宗教和地区界限而深度分裂。本文旨在考察从威廉二世即位到第一次世界大战前夕，德国国内政治的关键结构、主要参与者和核心矛盾。
1. The Constitutional Framework | 宪法框架
The German Empire’s constitution of 1871 established a federal structure that combined authoritarian monarchy with limited parliamentary participation. The Kaiser appointed the Chancellor, who was responsible solely to the Emperor, not to the Reichstag. While the Reichstag was elected by universal male suffrage, it possessed limited legislative power: it could approve or reject budgets and legislation, but it could not initiate most policies or remove the Chancellor from office.
1871 年的德意志帝国宪法确立了一个将专制君主制与有限议会参与相结合的联邦结构。皇帝任命宰相，宰相仅对皇帝负责，而非对帝国议会（Reichstag）负责。尽管帝国议会通过男性普选产生，但其立法权力有限：它可以批准或否决预算和立法，却不能主动提出大多数政策，也无法罢免宰相。
The Bundesrat, representing the constituent states, held significant power alongside the Kaiser. Prussia dominated this body, controlling 17 of 58 seats — enough to veto constitutional amendments. The system thus preserved Prussian aristocratic influence while providing a democratic veneer that satisfied some middle-class aspirations without fundamentally threatening the ruling elite.
代表各联邦州的联邦议会（Bundesrat）与皇帝共同掌握重要权力。普鲁士在这一机构中占据主导地位，拥有 58 个席位中的 17 席——足以否决宪法修正案。因此，这套制度在保留普鲁士贵族影响力的同时，提供了一层民主外观，满足部分中产阶级的诉求，却并未从根本上威胁统治精英的地位。
2. Wilhelm II’s Personal Rule | 威廉二世的个人统治
Wilhelm II’s accession in 1888 marked a decisive shift in German politics. The young Kaiser rejected Bismarck’s calculated balancing act, instead embracing a policy of ‘personal rule’ (persönliches Regiment). Wilhelm believed in the divine right of kings and viewed the monarchy as the sole legitimate source of political authority. His restless temperament and impulsive interventions in policy-making created chronic instability at the highest levels of government.
1888 年威廉二世的即位标志着德国政治的决定性转折。这位年轻的皇帝摒弃了俾斯麦精心算计的平衡策略，转而拥抱“个人统治”（persönliches Regiment）政策。威廉相信君权神授，将君主制视为政治权威的唯一合法来源。他躁动不安的性格和对决策过程的冲动干预，在政府最高层制造了长期的不稳定。
Wilhelm’s relationship with Otto von Bismarck deteriorated rapidly. The ageing Chancellor, who had dominated German and European politics for nearly three decades, found himself increasingly at odds with the young Kaiser’s ambitions. In March 1890, Bismarck was dismissed — a watershed moment that symbolised the transition from the Bismarckian system to Wilhelmine ‘personal rule’. Subsequent Chancellors — Caprivi, Hohenlohe, Bülow, and Bethmann Hollweg — were increasingly servile to the Emperor, their tenure often cut short by Wilhelm’s whims or by the irreconcilable pressures of parliamentary politics.
威廉与奥托·冯·俾斯麦的关系迅速恶化。这位主宰德国和欧洲政治近三十年的年迈宰相，发现自己与年轻皇帝的雄心日益格格不入。1890 年 3 月，俾斯麦被罢免——这一分水岭事件象征着从俾斯麦体系向威廉“个人统治”的过渡。此后的历任宰相——卡普里维、霍恩洛厄、比洛和贝特曼·霍尔韦格——对皇帝日益恭顺，其任期往往因威廉的反复无常或议会政治中不可调和的压力而缩短。
3. The Party System and Political Fragmentation | 政党体系与政治碎片化
The Wilhelmine party system mirrored the deep divisions within German society. The Conservative Party (Konservative Partei) drew support from Prussian aristocrats (Junkers), Lutheran pastors, and wealthy agrarians. They championed protective tariffs on grain, anti-socialist legislation, and the preservation of aristocratic privilege. The National Liberal Party (Nationalliberale Partei) represented the propertied middle class, combining support for German industrial expansion with a preference for liberal reforms only within the existing constitutional framework.
威廉时代的政党制度折射出德国社会内部的深刻分裂。保守党（Konservative Partei）支持者主要来自普鲁士贵族（容克）、路德宗牧师和富裕的农业利益集团。他们拥护谷物保护性关税、反社会主义立法和贵族特权的维护。民族自由党（Nationalliberale Partei）代表有产中产阶级，支持德国工业扩张，但同时偏好仅在现有宪法框架内进行自由改革。
More challenging to the established order was the Social Democratic Party (SPD), which grew from a fringe group outlawed by Bismarck’s Anti-Socialist Laws to the single largest party in the Reichstag by 1912, winning 110 of 397 seats. Despite revolutionary rhetoric inherited from Marxism, the SPD’s practical program — as outlined in the Erfurt Program of 1891 — aimed at incremental reforms through electoral participation. The party’s continued excluded from government despite its popular mandate became a central contradiction of Wilhelmine politics. The Centre Party (Zentrum), representing Catholic interests, occupied the middle ground, frequently holding the balance of power and negotiating with both Left and Right.
对既有秩序更具挑战性的是社会民主党（SPD）。该党从被俾斯麦《反社会主义非常法》取缔的边缘组织，成长为 1912 年帝国议会中最大的政党，赢得 397 席中的 110 席。尽管继承了马克思主义的革命言论，但社会民主党的实践纲领——以 1891 年《爱尔福特纲领》为标志——旨在通过选举参与实现渐进式改革。该党尽管拥有广泛民意授权却被排斥在政府之外，这成为威廉时代政治的核心矛盾之一。代表天主教利益的中ic党（Zentrum）则占据中间立场，经常掌握权力平衡，与左右两翼均有谈判。
4. Sammlungspolitik: The Politics of Rallying the Bourgeoisie | “集合政策”：拉拢资产阶级的政治
Following Bismarck’s dismissal, his successors sought to construct a new political foundation for the Reich. The concept of ‘Sammlungspolitik’ — the rallying or gathering together of all conservative and bourgeois forces against the twin threats of socialism and social democracy — emerged during the 1890s but gained its fullest expression under Chancellor Bülow in the 1907 ‘Hottentot election’ of 1907, when a conservative-liberal coalition was assembled against the Catholic Centre and the SPD.
俾斯麦被罢免后，他的继任者试图为帝国构建新的政治基础。“集合政策”（Sammlungspolitik）——即集结一切保守派和资产阶级力量以对抗社会主义与社会民主这双重威胁——的理念在 1890 年代浮现，但在比洛宰相主政期间得到了最充分的体现。1907 年，时值“霍屯督选举”，保守派与自由派结成一个联盟，以对抗天主教中ic党和社会民主党。
The ‘Bill of Associations’ (Reichsvereinsgesetz) of 1908 and the Reichstag’s budget conflicts of 1906–09 reveal how Sammlungspolitik functioned in practice. Tariff protection for Junker agriculture, naval expansion for heavy industry, and anti-socialist rhetoric served as the glue binding together otherwise divergent interests. Yet Sammlungspolitik was inherently unstable: the alliance between agrarian, industrial, and petty-bourgeois interests repeatedly fractured under the strain of conflicting economic demands, such as the question of whether to prioritise protective grain tariffs or shipping interests.
1908 年的《帝国结社法》（Reichsvereinsgesetz）以及 1906–09 年间帝国议会关于预算的冲突，揭示了“集合政策”在实践中的运作方式。保护容克农业的关税、服务重工业的海军扩张以及反社会主义言论，是将利益本不相同的力量黏合在一起的纽带。然而，“集合政策”本身是不稳定的：农业、工业和城市小资产阶级利益的联盟，在贸易保护与海军预算等相互冲突的经济诉求之压力下屡屡破裂。
5. Militarism and the Military’s Political Role | 军国主义与军队的政治角色
The Prussian-German military occupied an extraordinary position in Wilhelmine politics. The Kaiser’s authority as ‘Supreme War Lord’ was exercised through the Military Cabinet (Militärkabinett), which was entirely independent of civil government oversight. The army operated as a ‘state within a state’, with its own jurisdiction — military courts handled offences by soldiers and civilians in military zones without appeal to civilian judges.
普鲁士—德国军队在威廉时代的政治中占据着非同寻常的地位。皇帝作为“最高战争领主”的权力通过军事内廷（Militärkabinett）行使，该机构完全不受文官政府监督。军队如同“国中之国”，拥有独立司法权——军事法庭审理士兵及军事区域内的平民案件，且不得向文官法官上诉。
This military autonomy had profound political consequences. The officer corps, drawn overwhelmingly from the aristocracy, regarded civilian politicians with contempt and viewed parliamentary democracy as a foreign corruption. Military leaders repeatedly advocated preventive war — most notably General Alfred von Waldersee, who proposed attacking France while Russia was still recovering from its 1905 defeat. Even when such extreme proposals were resisted, the military’s capacity to overrule civilian judgement in crises — such as the Zabern Affair of 1913, when army officers brutally mistreated Alsatian civilians and the military tribunal exonerated them — demonstrated the militarised nature of the entire state apparatus.
这种军事自主权产生了深远的政治后果。军官团成员绝大多数来自贵族阶层，他们蔑视文官政治家，将议会民主视为外来腐蚀品。军方领导层一再鼓吹先发制人的战争——最典型的是阿尔弗雷德·冯·瓦尔德泽大将，他曾在俄国尚未从 1905 年战败中恢复时就提议进攻法国。即使在极端提议遭到否决之时，军方在危机中凌驾于文官判断之上的能力——例如 1913 年的察伯恩事件，军队军官粗暴虐待阿尔萨斯平民而军事法庭却宣布他们无罪——充分暴露了整个国家机器的军事化本质。
6. Nationalism, Social Darwinism, and the Radical Right | 民族主义、社会达尔文主义与激进右翼
The Wilhelmine era witnessed the emergence of a new, more aggressive form of nationalism that drew upon Social Darwinist ideas of racial supremacy and the survival of the fittest. Organisations such as the Pan-German League (Alldeutscher Verband), founded in 1891, promoted the unification of all German-speaking peoples, the acquisition of colonies, and the establishment of Germany as the dominant global power. The Navy League (Flottenverein), established in 1898 with strong industrial backing, propagated the ‘world politics’ vision through mass propaganda.
威廉时代见证了一种更激进的新民族主义兴起，其思想根源是种族优越论和适者生存的社会达尔文主义信条。1891 年成立的泛德意志联盟（Alldeutscher Verband）等组织，鼓吹统一所有德语民族、获取殖民地、将德国打造成主导世界的强国。1898 年成立、获工业界强力资助的海军联盟（Flottenverein）则通过群众宣传传播“世界政策”愿景。
These pressure groups, although unable to elect representatives directly, exerted considerable influence on government. Through their close connections with the naval command and foreign office, particularly under Grand Admiral Alfred von Tirpitz, they helped push successive governments toward a more aggressive foreign and colonial policy. Simultaneously, these movements espoused virulent anti-Semitic rhetoric, demanding that Jewish citizens be excluded from public office, the military, and academic positions. The Union of German Students (Kyffhäuser-Verband) passed an antisemitic ‘Aryan paragraph’ in 1893, foreshadowing the racism that would grow in the twentieth century.
这些压力集团虽不能直接选举代表，却对政府施加重大的影响。通过与海军司令部及外交部的密切关系——尤其是在海军上将阿尔弗雷德·冯·提尔皮茨的领导下——它们推动了历届政府采取更为激进的对外与殖民政策。与此同时，这些运动宣扬猛烈的反犹言论，要求将犹太公民排除在公职、军队和学术职位之外。德国学生联合会（Kyffhäuser-Verband）于 1893 年通过了反犹的“雅利安条款”，这预示了二十世纪将蔓延开来的种族主义。
7. The Naval Expansion and Its Domestic Logic | 海军扩张及其国内逻辑
One of the defining features of Wilhelmine Germany was the massive expansion of the Imperial Navy. The First Navy Law of 1898 and the Second Navy Law of 1900, sponsored by Admiral Tirpitz, authorised a fleet powerful enough to challenge British naval supremacy. This unprecedented programme had a dual purpose: to project German power globally and to provide a unifying domestic cause that could bridge class divisions and mobilise popular support for the monarchy.
威廉时代德国的标志性特征之一，是帝国海军的空前扩张。由提尔皮茨海军上将主导的 1898 年《第一海军法》和 1900 年《第二海军法》，授权建立一支足以挑战英国海上霸权的舰队。这一史无前例的计划具有双重目的：在全球投射德国实力，同时为国内提供一种弥合阶级分歧、动员民众支持君主制的统一事业。
Domestically, the naval programme proved extraordinarily popular. It created employment in shipyards, promised social mobility through the rapidly expanding officer corps, and offered the masses a spectacle of German greatness. The Navy Law of 1900 even contained a ‘retirement clause’ that exempted naval officers from the general retirement age, signalling that the fleet was intended as a permanent institution. Tirpitz established the Navy Office as a propaganda machine, distributing millions of pamphlets and organising public lectures to build pressure on the Reichstag to approve ever-larger budgets. While successful in the short term, the naval arms race imposed enormous fiscal burdens, led to diplomatic isolation vis-à-vis Britain, and created a powerful interest group whose demands for ever-increasing battleship construction strained the federal budget.
在国内，海军计划获得了异乎寻常的支持。它创造了船厂就业，通过迅速扩张的军官队伍许诺社会流动机会，并为民众提供了德意志伟大图景的壮丽景观。1900 年的《海军法》甚至包含一项“退休条款”，规定海军军官不受一般退休年龄限制，意味着舰队旨在成为永久性的机构。提尔皮茨将海军办公室打造成宣传机器，发放数百万份小册子，组织公众讲座，以向帝国议会施加批准更大预算的压力。尽管短期内成效显著，但海军军备竞赛带来了巨大的财政负担，导致德国对英外交孤立，同时孕育了一个要求不断增大战列舰建造以突破联邦预算限制的强有力利益集团。
8. ”Weltpolitik’ and the Limits of Domestic Consensus | “世界政策”与国内共识的限度
Wilhelm II’s proclamation of ”Weltpolitik” (world policy) in the 1890s marked a decisive declaration of Germany’s ambition to become a global power. The acquisition of colonies in Africa and the Pacific, the Baghdād Railway project, and the presence of German gunboats in every ocean all embodied this ambition. Yet Weltpolitik was not merely a foreign policy: it served a critical domestic function of unifying a fractured society behind a vision of national greatness.
威廉二世在 1890 年代宣布的“世界政策”（Weltpolitik）标志着德国要成为全球强国的雄心宣言。在非洲和太平洋获取殖民地、巴格达铁路项目、以及德国炮舰在世界各大洋的巡弋，都体现了这一雄心。然而，世界政策不仅仅是外交政策：它还发挥了一项关键的国内功能——以一种民族伟大的愿景将分裂的社会团结起来。
The 1905 ‘Moroccan crisis’ exposed the limits of this approach. Germany’s attempt to challenge French influence in Morocco, orchestrated through Foreign Office personal diplomacy with minimal cabinet input, isolated Germany diplomatically while the government used the crisis to rally nationalist feeling at home. The resulting settlement, which handed Morocco to France in exchange for minor territorial compensation in the Congo, humiliated Germany and revealed that the Weltpolitik project lacked the strategic coherence required for sustained success. Domestically, these crises reinforced a narrative of ‘encirclement’ (Einkreisung) by hostile powers — creating a siege mentality that served the military-industrial interests while suffocating more sober voices who proposed cooperation with Britain and France.
1905 年的“摩洛哥危机”暴露了这一方针的限度。德国试图挑战法国在摩洛哥的影响，外交部在没有充分内阁参与的情况下推行个人化外交，结果导致德国在外交上陷入孤立，而政府同时利用危机来提升国内民族主义情绪。最终达成的解决方案将摩洛哥交予法国，仅以刚果部分领土作出赔偿，这使德国蒙羞，并揭示“世界政策”项目缺乏持续成功所需的战略连贯性。在国内，这些危机强化了“被敌对势力包围”（Einkreisung）的叙事——滋生了被围困心态，这种心态服务于军事工业利益，同时压制了主张与英法合作的那些较为理性的声音。
9. The Daily Telegraph Affair and the Erosion of Monarchical Authority | 《每日电讯报》事件与君主权威的侵蚀
The 1908 Daily Telegraph affair represented a turning point in public attitudes toward Wilhelmine rule. The Kaiser, in an interview published in the respected British newspaper, made a series of intemperate remarks — claiming that Germany was not actually hostile to Britain, that he had supported the British during the Boer War, and that German public opinion was Anglophile. These comments created a storm of outrage in Britain and equally in Germany, where the public resented Wilhelm’s apparent willingness to abandon German interests in the pursuit of British friendship.
1908 年的《每日电讯报》事件是公众对威廉时代统治态度转变的转折点。这位皇帝在接受这家英国权威报纸采访时发表了一系列不谨慎言论——声称德国实际上并不敌视英国，自己曾支持布尔战争期间的英国，以及德国公众舆论是亲英的。这些言论在英国引发轩然大波，在德国国内也同样引起愤慨——民众对于威廉为追求对英友谊而显得愿意放弃德国利益感到愤怒。
The constitutional crisis that followed was unprecedented. The Reichstag debated a motion to constrain the Kaiser’s powers of personal commentary; Chancellor Bülow, who had approved the text for publication, was forced to accept a vote of no confidence in his handling of the affair — the first such motion to pass in German history. Although the Kaiser retreated temporarily into silence, the damage to the monarchy’s legitimacy was permanent. The affair demonstrated that the constitution, designed to check parliamentary power, could not prevent the Kaiser’s reckless personal interventions from embarrassing the state. From 1909 onward, Wilhelm’s authority eroded progressively along with his influence over government.
随后的宪政危机是史无前例的。帝国议会就是否限制皇帝个人发表言论的权力展开了辩论；对稿件内容审核批准的宰相比洛，被迫接受了一项对其处理方式的不信任动议——这是德国历史上首次通过不信任动议。尽管皇帝暂时退居沉默，但对君主制合法性的损害却是永久性的。这一事件表明，这部旨在制约议会权力的宪法，无法阻止皇帝鲁莽的个人干预给国家带来难堪。从 1909 年起，威廉的权威及其对政府的影响逐步削弱。
10. Sozialpolitik and the ‘New Course’ | 社会政策与“新路线”
Despite its authoritarian character, the Wilhelmine state could not ignore the enormous social question — the plight of an industrial working class that numbered in the millions. Bismarck’s state-sponsored social insurance schemes (sickness, accident, and old-age insurance) had been designed to undercut SPD appeal; his successors continued and expanded these programmes.
尽管威权色彩浓厚，威廉时代的国家无法忽视巨大的社会问题——数以百万计的产业工人阶级的困境。俾斯麦以国家主导的社会保险计划（疾病、意外和养老保险）来削弱社会民主党的号召力；其继任者延续并扩大了这些计划。
The ”New Course” of Chancellor Caprivi (1890–94) attempted to moderate the sharpest edges of class conflict through negotiated settlement of the miners’ strike in 1893 and tariff reductions that lowered food prices. Yet these initiatives met with only partial success. The intransigence of employers, particularly in heavy industry, meant that collective bargaining remained stunted. The massive industrial expansion created unprecedented urbanisation, dislocation, and class resentment, while the SPD consolidated its position as the mass party espousing the working-class cause.
卡普里维宰相的“新路线”（1890–94 年）试图通过协商解决 1893 年矿工罢工以及降低关税以压低食品价格来缓和阶级冲突。然而这些举措只取得了部分成功。雇主的顽固立场——尤其是重工业界的抵制——使集体谈判机制难以成长。庞大的工业扩张带来了空前的城市化、社会脱序和阶级怨恨，而社会民主党则巩固了其作为工人阶级群众政党的地位。
11. The 1912 Election and the Bloc System in Crisis | 1912 年选举与集团体系的危机
The 1912 Reichstag election marked a critical political climax. The SPD achieved its greatest electoral victory, emerging as the dominant party in the Reichstag. The Liberal parties, despite participating in the conservative ‘Bülow bloc’, suffered substantial losses. This outcome exposed a fundamental paradox: the electoral system, designed to give the masses a voice, had delivered power to precisely the party the government was committed to excluding from office.
1912 年的帝国议会选举标志着一场关键的政治高潮。社会民主党取得其最大的选举胜利，成为帝国议会第一大党。自由党派虽参与了保守派的“比洛集团”，却蒙受重大损失。这一结果暴露出一个根本性悖论：这套旨在赋予民众声音的选举制度，恰恰将权力交给了政府坚决排斥于执政之外的那个政党。
From 1912 onward, Germany was governed through a ”shadow constitution”: legally, the Chancellor and Kaiser retained authority; practically, no budget could be passed without SPD support, which the party was willing to grant provisionally in exchange for moderate social reforms. The need for formal SPD support in the Reichstag coexisted awkwardly with official government declarations that the SPD was a hostile and disloyal movement, unworthy of political recognition. By 1914, this contradictory situation had produced a political paralysis — the central domestic configuration in which Germany entered the First World War.
从 1912 年起，德国通过一种“影子宪法”来治理：法律上，宰相和皇帝保留权威；实践上，没有社会民主党的支持任何预算都无法通过，而社会民主党愿意以温和社会改革作为交换条件提供临时支持。一方面政府需要社会民主党在议会中的正式支持，另一方面官方又公开宣称该党是敌视国家的、不忠诚的运动，不配获得政治承认——这种矛盾共处在1914 年时已导致政治瘫痪——这正是德国参加第一次世界大战时的国内基本格局。
12. Assessment and Historical Debate | 总体评价与史学争论
Historians remain profoundly divided over the nature of Wilhelmine domestic politics. The ‘Bielefeld school’ centred on Hans-Ulrich Wehler and Jürgen Kocka argues that the German ruling elites consciously pursued a strategy of ‘social imperialism’ and ‘authoritarian manipulation’ — using nationalism, militarism, and Weltpolitik as instruments to divert mass discontent and preserve their privilege. In this view, Wilhelmine Germany was a ‘belated nation’ whose pre-modern power structures remained fundamentally incompatible with industrial modernity, producing a unique and dangerous form of political pathology.
历史学家对威廉时代国内政治的本质仍然存在深刻分歧。以汉斯-乌尔里希·韦勒和于尔根·科卡为代表的“比勒费尔德学派”认为，德国统治精英自觉地推行“社会帝国主义”和“威权操纵”策略——以民族主义、军国主义和世界政策为工具，转移大众不满、维持自身特权。按照这种观点，威廉时代的德国是一个“迟来的民族”，其前现代的权力结构在根本上与工业现代性不相容，从而产生了一种独特而危险的政治病理形态。
Revisionist historians such as David Blackbourn and Geoff Eley, while accepting the authoritarian features, argue that we should take the Wilhelmine regime’s reformist capacities more seriously: the Reichstag did possess power, public opinion mattered, and many civil, legal, and social reforms were enacted in these decades. For them, the decisive issue was not an inevitable trajectory to catastrophe, but a contingent political struggle in which alternative futures were possible even as the First World War ultimately imposed the most destructive outcome.
以大卫·布莱克伯恩和杰夫·艾利为代表的修正派史学家，虽然接受威权特征，但认为应当更认真地对待威廉政权的改革能力：帝国议会确实拥有一定权力，公众舆论有意义，这几十年的确推动了众多民事、法律和社会改革。在他们看来，关键问题并非德意志必然滑向灾难，而是偶然性的政治博弈——即使第一次世界大战最终带来了最具毁灭性的结局，但当时其他可能的未来依然是存在的。
The domestic politics of Wilhelmine Germany thus remains a subject of scholarly debate precisely because it speaks to fundamental questions about the relationship between modernisation, democracy, and authoritarian power. What remains undeniable is that Germany’s peculiar mixture of democratic forms and autocratic substance created a political culture of escalating tension, one in which the military’s influence, the impotence of parliament, and a citizenship increasingly mobilised in nationalist and socialist camps made the collapse of the entire system an ever-present possibility long before 1914.
威廉时代德国的国内政治之所以至今仍然是学术争论的课题，恰恰在于它触及了关于现代化、民主与威权权力之间关系的根本问题。不可否认的是，德国民主形式与专制实质的奇特混合，塑造了一种紧张不断升级的政治文化——在这样的文化中，军队的影响、议会的无力，以及同时向民族主义和社会主义阵营日益动员起来的公民群体，使整个体制的崩解早在 1914 年之前就已经成为一种随时可能发生的前景。
Published by TutorHao | 历史 Revision Series | aleveler.com
更多咨询请联系16621398022（同微信）
屏轩国际教育cambridge primary/secondary checkpoint, cat4, ukiset,ukcat,igcse,alevel,PAT,STEP,MAT, ibdp,ap,ssat,sat,sat2课程辅导，国外大学本科硕士研究生博士课程论文辅导